Spirit Descent – Seven Chapters in Minor

By Gruesome Greg

I must say that I know next to nothing about this German band, for whom this is their second album. Mind you, this sounds like a pretty decent slice of epic doom a la Candlemass, with tunes like “Dawn of Mankind” and “Owner of Fifty Names” displaying the latter’s slow, brooding deposition—the opening of “Love Turned to Stone” even reminds me of “Solitude.” Though Spirit Descent’s singer’s got a bit of an odd accent, he does have the pipes to pull off the more-operatic style this subgenre requires, which is definitely a plus.

“The Tragedy of Captain Scott” is a lengthy tale stretching nearly fourteen minutes. A poor man’s “Rime of the Ancient Mariner,” considering the subject matter, but I’d liken it more to “Pieces of Your Smile,” the lengthiest tune from Argus’ latest, albeit with a tad too much spoken word. On that note, these guys sound sorta like a poor man’s Argus to me. The personnel is in place (three guitars, operatic vocals), but they seem more dirge-like, less dynamic. That’s not entirely a bad thing, mind you…

In fact, if this band’s MO is to copy Candlemass and Argus as closely as they can, they’ve hit the mark. I gotta dock ‘em a couple points for originality, but full marks for execution are well-deserved.

(PsycheDOOMelic)

Comments

8 responses to “Spirit Descent – Seven Chapters in Minor”

  1. Slowtomic Avatar
    Slowtomic

    … ok. You dont know the german metal scene.
    But do you think its enough to give a comment?
    Dont think so! I ve bought the CD and it is great. Also seen them live and
    what a surprise: Awesome!!! Jan is a real frontman.
    He doesnt only sing.He ll get you and shows
    you the story.
    This guys rock!!! You dont think so?
    So you dont ve a heart and only ears! 10 of 10 points

  2. Gruesome Greg Avatar

    Whoa buddy, your English obviously isn’t that great. This was a generally positive review; a 7.5 means it’s better than three-quarters of the shit that comes my way. I would not call it a perfect 10, though. There are bands out there that do this style of doom better.

    No, I don’t know every underground band from Deutschland, but I do know doom, and yet I’ve never heard of these guys before. This is only their second album, I think. Instead of vomiting out some PR bullshit like “This epic doom band will melt your face off!,” I’m going to be upfront about it. If I say that I wouldn’t know them from a Nena cover band, it’s to show that I’m coming in without any preconceptions or expectations. Frankly, I don’t see how you can find that offensive, unless you’re their manager or something…

    And if you are their manager, Klaus, then you’ve clearly got some work to do. I know I’m not the only reviewer out there who isn’t intimately familiar with Spirit Descent.

    Peace,

    Greg

  3. Andreas Libera Avatar
    Andreas Libera

    Cheers Greg !

    To be honest, I don’t know, why there is any discussion behind my back, it only seems like some sort of misunderstanding…..

    The only thing, I personally stumbled across was “poor man’s Argus”…I mean until I read this review, I never heard of Argus before (!!!), so I cannot really be inspired by a band, I never listened to before ;).
    In Germany, if you call something “poor man’s…” it means, it is really, really poor and not just a “light”-version of it.

    I must say, I am not upset or anything like that about a 7,5 rate, if it is your opinion, I am fine with that, no problem, as always, you cannot argue on taste or opinions…;)

    If we ever should play overseas, we’ll get you on a guest-list, we’ll have a drink and it should be fine !

    Peace

    Andreas (Spirit Descent, main songwriter)

  4. Slowtomic Avatar
    Slowtomic

    I’m not the manager or familiar with them. I only have an opinion to your review of a band you dont know. Anyway… You are angry and you think everything you ll wirte is the only truth. I dont care…. 10/10

  5. Andreas Libera Avatar
    Andreas Libera

    BTW:
    @Slowtomic: Thanks a lot for your support and loyality !

  6. Gruesome Greg Avatar

    Angry? Not in the slightest. Try amused. If you understood English better, you’d see that I’m laughing at you, Udo. I’m fine with other people’s opinions, but when they suggest that I “dont ve a heart and only ears” (sic), they can expect me to respond in kind.

    Peace,

    Greg

  7. Andreas Libera Avatar
    Andreas Libera

    @Greg: Another detail, but you are not the first one to get it wrong: The title is “Seven Chapters in A Minor”, not just…Minor….

    Thanks !

    Cheers

    Andreas

  8. Gruesome Greg Avatar

    Hey Andreas, the digital promo sent out by PsycheDOOMelic dropped the A from the title, so you might wanna take that up with your label.

    As for the Argus comment, fair enough. I guess I wish that more modern doom bands were as good as them, haha. That said, if you guys ever somehow make it over to Toronto, I would definitely come out and see ya. Apparently, your live shows are legendary. 😉

    Peace,

    Greg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.